What’s different with the International Kindle (store) – A review

22 10 2009

I received my International Kindle 2 yesterday. Following are my observations an some research on the differences for US and non-US customers.

General

Please allow me some general remarks to the Kindle 2 as a new user to this device.

  1. So far I like the experience and it delivers everything I expected. The Kindle could become a replacement for printed books in the casual category. I strongly doubt that I would like for any books with extended graphics or layout on the Kindle. It’s an ok alternative for accessing newspapers that aren’t  available locally. I’m however missing the layout of a newspaper.
  2. I previously had tested a Sony eBook reader and was very annoyed with the screen blackening per page change. Kindles page turning experience is ok, but just ok.
  3. Unpacking the device was, compared to unpacking an Apple device, very spartan.
  4. Overall Kindle UI experience is ok for me. Some menu options are weirdly placed (for me), I’m wondering why the ‘Home’ button is located on top of the “next page” button and not nearby the joystick.  
  5. I appreciate amaon’s the nice gesture to refund US$20 due to the latest price reduction of the device to US$ 259.
  6. Whispersync for reading position is working between Kindle and iPhone client.

International Aspects

I ordered my Kindle with my amazon.com account, which has a US address and a European address in my profile.I will however use the Kindle mostly in Europe.

Amazon currently distinguishes your physical location only based on your originating IP address and the allocated physical location of this address. Using my desktop  web browser and a VPN (same on the iPhone) I can suggest to the amazon.com store a different physical location. With the built in GSM module this currently is not possible.

As far as the Kindle shop is concerned I will maintain my US location. Therefore I need to do all my shopping with a desktop web-browser or the iPhone over VPN and can’t use the Kindle built in shop connection.

This location setting gives me the following advantages:

  • Primary reason: Ability to order from a larger selection of books. Detailed drill down on numbers of books in country stores to be found here:
      Thumbnail via WebSnapr: http://blogkindle.com/2009/10/kindle-international-coverage-update/
  • Freedom of choice whether I want to use the wireless (GSM) connection for the download (and pay for it) or if I want to leverage my existing internet connection and download via PC.
  • Ability to use the experimental Web-browser (even when roaming).
  • Ability to subscribe to blogs.

Comparison between the US- and non-US-Kindle Store

To start of, the US store has a significantly larger choice of books. In the European version I couldn’t find a significant number of 2009 releases. (All prices below as of 2009-10-22).

 

US Kindle Store

Non-US Kindle Store

The Lost Symbol by Dan Brown

$9.99

Not available

Valentine’s Exile by E.E. Knight

$8.39

$8.39
(includes wireless delivery outside of US)

Pursuit of Honor by Vince Flynn

$9.99

$11.99
(includes wireless delivery outside of US)

New York Times subscription (*)

$13.99

$27.99
(includes wireless delivery outside of US)

Frankfurter Allgemeine Subscription (*)

$14.99

$27.99

(includes wireless delivery outside of US)

Blog subscriptions

beginning with $0.99

Not available

International Book Service

$1.99 per download

included in book price

International Current Issue Service

$1.99 per issue

included in issue / subscription price

International Subscription Service (1)

$4.99/week (week = 7 days) including all subscribed blogs, magazines and subscriptions

included in issue / subscription price
blog subscription not available

Personal Document Delivery

$0.99 per megabyte

$0.99 per megabyte

The International Subscription Service can be activated as a recurring option. When enabled you’ll pay US 4.99 per week, whenever the Kindle is connected to a roaming network and is downloading blogs, magazine or newspaper issues.

Summary

As stated previously:

The Kindle by far isn’t the perfect device. But it will do for now.

The distinction between residence, especially regarding the available content is bad. But there are ways (VPN) to circumvent the restrictions.

Additional fees for wireless delivery are not nice. But I understand that the data network roaming system overall is a pretty nasty thing and amazon needed to play by.

Overall I’m looking forward using the Kindle.





International Kindle – Yes I can!

7 10 2009

After reading the Amazon announcement I immediately ordered a International Kindle. This happened out of impulse, but also with some preparation.

Amazon International Kindle

For a while I was considering buying a US only version. But the additional steps required and the total cost to get the device to Europe was too much for me. Now the price is ok and the delivery seems to be seamless.

I suppose this won’t be the final eBook device for me. I currently envision that for each language I might buy a different device. I suppose that German publishers want to pursue a different way than working with Amazon. Also form factor (size of display), resolution and network connection will be enhanced over time. However after so many years of waiting for instant access to English books whatever solution is right for me. Now! Yes I can!  

History

My appetite for English books started in the eighties off last century. During high-school my language skills had matured far enough to enjoy the original version of a book.

But in Germany it was difficult to obtain English reading material. International press shops in large train stations had a very limited offering. University city book stores that carried sometimes carried two handful of titles, mostly as paper backs. And they could order books on request. I had to provide them with exact title, author, publisher and order number. With this information they reached out to their agent in the US or UK and tried to obtain the book. The whole process normally took 2-3 month per book and was extremely expensive. In some cases I paid factor three compared to the suggested retail price in the US. If a book was published in the UK it sometimes was delivered faster and “only” cost twice as much. But remember: This was pre-Internet and pre-Amazon.

During the nineties the situation got better and better. With CD-ROM becoming available I could obtain catalogues of books in print. This helped to better identify the exact book I was looking for.

Shortly thereafter first mail-order distributors started to collect orders in Germany with an online ordering system (still pre-Internet). So the complete process from start to end only took a month and the prices came down significantly.

With Amazon in Germany and the Internet there was no longer any difference between locally published books and other books. Often the book I wanted was on stock and got delivered within a week.

And soon the delivery process will become electronically without any significant delay.

Perfect World?

I don’t think that the current Kindle is the perfect device. The downside aspects:

Locked in Amazon DRM

I know that with the books I’m ordering from Amazon I’m locked down in their enclosed DRM world. But for the “typical” fiction I really don’t care. I normally read a book, put it in the shelf and when space runs out a triage process kicks in. Some books are given away to friends and family, others go to a public book collection service and some just vanish.

No WLAN / GSM download has extra cost

I would like to have a WiFi version of a ebook reader. With my MiFi 2352 I’m equipped with GSM connectivity where ever I go. And  the extra cost for any “International” = GSM download from the Kindle store is not nice, but understandably. For a long time there was a rumor that Amazon was planning to move internationally, but the talks with at least German GSM providers broke down this summer. Carrier quotes for the data traffic are rumored to be the deal breaker. Now leveraging AT&T is expensive but it removes plenty of complexity for Amazon and also for the average consumer.

Form Factor

I’m really curios how good or bad my reading experience will be in the long run. My expectation is that reading a “normal” eBook will be fine, but reading and browsing a newspaper will be challenging. For me the nice side effect will hopefully be the availability of “Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung” with up to date content.

I’ll keep you posted.

– PTL –